Phillipine Muslim leaders’ hopes on Bangsamoro run out


With just three days left before Congress adjourns for election campaigning, a law seeking to create an autonomous political entity in the Philippines south and bring closure to a 17-year peace process between the government and the country’s one time largest Muslim rebel group is still to be ratified.

This week, Muslim lawmakers expressed little hope that Bangsamoro Basic Law will pass through the Senate and the House of Representatives before new leaders — and with them, a new political outlook — are sworn in on the back of May’s vote, raising the chances that large-scale conflict could return to the country’s mineral-rich — but impoverished — southern region.

In a statement emailed to Anadolu Agency, Lanao del Sur District Representative Pangalian Balindong expressed severe disappointment that the House has so far failed to pass the law on its second reading.

“It is the lowest and saddest day of my legislative work,” said Balindong, who is also deputy house leader for the predominantly Muslim region of Mindanao.

“Today, with a heavy heart and a sense of foreboding, I close the book of hope for the passage [of the law]. 51 public hearings, 200 hours of committee level debates, and eight months of consultations are all put to waste — thrown into the abyss of uncertainty and darkness.”

The law’s expected passage has now been delayed by at least ten months amid disagreements among lawmakers — led by Senator Ferdinand Marcos Jr., the son of Ferdinand Marcos who ruled the Philippines for 21 years – who have presented a substitute bill to Congress that includes amendments to around 80 percent of the original draft.

Rebel group the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) has said, however, that it will not accept a diluted version, and at one point threatened to end decommissioning if a watered down version is passed.

Balindong, who belongs to the influential and well respected Maranao clan — the second-largest Muslim group in the Philippines — underlined in his statement that Moro legislators are outnumbered 28-1 in the senate.

“We are only ten lone voices in the wilderness of bias, prejudice and hatred,” he said, and accused the House of collectively failing the Bangsamoro people — the country’s indigenous Muslims.

The lawmaker highlighted the role of the Mamasapano incident — in which 44 elite police commandos were shot dead by the MILF and splinter group the Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters as they sought to apprehend a terrorist — in the discussions.

 He claimed that the deaths fleshed out the biases and prejudices of those against the Moro and proved a setback to legislative deliberations on the law.

“[T]he Mamasapano misencounter has labeled us again as terrorists, extremists, enemies, traitors, and murderers. I have personally witnessed and heard the bashing and lashing against the Moros not only over the media but right in this hall of Congress,” he wrote.

“Because of the Mamasapano, many of those who supported the BBL wittingly or unwittingly punished the Moro people by denying us of the required votes and even the quorum to deliberate the BBL.”

Balindong also expressed concerns that with the looming threat of radicalism in the world, the failure to pass the law would entice young Moro to join radical groups instead of taking the path to peace.

“It is a disaster that extremists can easily exploit… For the Moro people, who have resisted subjugation for the past four hundred years, I am afraid the fight will continue, until there is justice. And more painful on my part is the knowledge that we have failed the next generation who will obviously inherit the vicious cycle of war and conflict.

On Thursday, House Speaker Feliciano Belmonte Jr. and Balindong said that even a miracle would no longer save the measure. Citing the three remaining days left before Congress adjourns for the election campaign period, Belmonte said there is no longer any chance for the BBL to be passed as the outgoing president, Benigno Aquino III, and the MILF had hoped.

“Realistically, the target of passing it in the House is remote,” Belmonte told reporters.

House Bill 5811 — the proposed Basic Law on the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region remains stuck in a period of amendments. The bill seeks to formalize the creation of a new political entity to replace the existing Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao and thus seal the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro peace agreement, signed March 27, 2014 between the government and MILF.

The president had prodded lawmakers to pass the measure, but the House has since been dogged by quorum problems.

Balindong claimed in his statement that most lawmakers showed no interest in passing the measure, even if an Ad Hoc panel on the Bangsamoro revised the draft bill by removing the opt-in provision, which would expand the core Bangsamoro area through a plebiscite and the provisions on the establishment of a Bangsamoro military command, police, auditing body, Civil Service Commission and poll body were also removed.

On Thursday, Rep. Tupay Loong — from the southern Muslim province of Sulu — shared Balindong’s frustration, saying that he is deeply saddened that after more than 17 years of arduous negotiations, the law has a very slim or no chance at all of being passed.

He not only blamed unwarranted suspicions against and mistrust in the Moro, but also what he claimed was a lack of interest by so many members of the House.

Earlier this week, MILF peace panel chair Mohagher Iqbal said that the optimism that Congress would pass the BBL is now “long buried and dead.”

“Chances are high that it will not pass at all,” Iqbal told reporters on the sidelines of Monday’s launch of the Journey to the Bangsamoro, which outlined various historical phases in the peace process.

“Signs are already pointing to that direction. There is lack of quorum in the House and I think, if it will not be passed these three days, I don’t think it will be passed at all,” he said.

“I don’t think the MILF would ever agree — or is capable — to negotiate again for such a long period of time. We miss this opportunity, I don’t think a similar opportunity will ever present itself again in a generation or two from now.”

Iqbal reiterated the MILF’s stand, that it will not accept a watered-down version of the BBL, and that decommissioning of MILF forces — overseen by Turkey’s Ambassador Mustafa Pulat — will not continue due to the failure to pass the law.

The BBL was to provide the legal structure to implement the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro peace agreement, signed March 27, 2014 between the government and MILF.

The Philippines elections are scheduled to take place May 9, with Filipinos voting for a new president, vice president, 12 senators, and a district representative, a party list representative, and provincial/city/municipal officials.

Aquino has been forced to stop down as Philippine presidents can only serve one six-year term of office.